These videos point out some of the problems with Harry Potter.
On December 3, 2014, Emily Heller wrote an article titled:
Why Your Favorite Harry Potter Character Actually Sucks
Here is what she has to say about Harry Potter.
Emily Heller: 1. Harry
Harry may be the most important character but he's definitely the most annoying. Seriously, he just angsted his way through the entire series. In fact, Ginny called him out on it at one point for being so self-absorbed that he forgot one of his closest friends had actually gone through something that he thought he was going through himself. Harry is consistently stubborn to the point of insanity. Things could have been so much easier for him if he asked for help instead of thinking he's the only one that can possibly understand complicated magical concepts. He's incredibly self-absorbed in that annoying way where he acts like he's being selfless. Saving the wizarding world doesn't give you an excuse to be a complete stinkface to your best friends. (Also, YOU FLARING IDIOT SIRIUS GAVE YOU A MAGICAL WAY TO CONTACT HIM DIRECTLY THAT YOU COMPLETELY IGNORED. HE'S DEAD BECAUSE YOU'RE BAD AT ACCEPTING GIFTS)
Ocean Elf: And because Dumbledore cooped him up in a horrible house of terrible childhood memories that sapped his will to live.
Please see what she and others wrote of Dumbledore on the above link.
Please see what's written about other characters on this link.
*
5 Reasons Why Harry Potter Is Actually The Worst Character In His Own Series
By CATHERINE KOVACH
Mar 21 2016 A person's thoughts about the best and worst Harry Potter characters can be polarizing, especially opinions about who may be overrated and underrated in the grand scope of the series. The Harry Potter universe is home to dozens upon dozens of characters and every individual reader has a different opinion. For example, I think that Remus Lupin is the best character in Harry Potter. Neville Longbottom comes in a very close second. I think that there needs to be a rewrite of the entire series where the main character is Hermione instead of Harry, because imagine how awesome that would be?
Ocean Elf: Ugh! None of those, thank you.
CATHERINE KOVACH: But more than anything else, I think that Harry Potter is an actual garbage human.
Ocean Elf: *Snicker*
CATHERINE KOVACH: Don't get upset ā you saw the title of the article.
Ocean Elf: Hahah! Good one.
CATHERINE KOVACH: That doesn't mean that the series is terrible, or even that Harry himself is terrible.
Ocean Elf: Huh? By that, if you mean he's not as bad as Voldy, I see your point. Otherwise, I'm a little confused.
CATHERINE KOVACH: I respect the fact that Harry's character flaws make him human. No person in this world could go through what he went through and come out adjusted, and I bet the upcoming Harry Potter and the Cursed Child vindicates me in that thought process.
Ocean Elf: Ugh. When does it stop?
CATHERINE KOVACH: Harry is a bit of a jerk, he yells at people, barely focuses on schoolwork, and doesn't seem to understand how human beings work. Below, I've come up with 5 very valid reasons why Harry Potter is actually the worst character in Harry Potter. Perhaps, if you read my reasons, you might agree.
1. He had a total lack of self awareness.
While this can be easily blamed on his teenagerhood, Harry doesn't seem to have a single idea of his effect on other human beings. This can also be blamed on the Dursleys raising him, but if you really look back and think about it, he never had any concept of his impact as a person ā good or bad. From the moment he first set foot into the Leaky Cauldron, he was praised and loved for being the Boy Who Lived, and yet he was constantly surprised when people were both nice or mean to him. When more people showed up at the Hog's Head Inn to discuss forming Dumbledore's Army, he was completely confused. Let's break this down, though, from day one at Hogwarts, he's been fighting trolls, basilisks, driving flying cars into murderous trees, basically being handed a spot on the Quidditch team in his first year, riding hippogriffs, being chosen as a special Hogwarts champion, and walking around collapsing because he shares a link with the most dangerous wizard ever.
If you were attending Hogwarts at the same time as Harry Potter, you could basically feel famous by association. You'd probably be dying to sit next to him at feasts. But instead of being aware of the responsibility of being cool, he instead scratches his head and goes, "Whoa people want me to teach them how to make patronouses?"
That makes him uncool.
2. He didn't fully understand what a wizarding war even meant.
All throughout Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Harry struggles with Umbridge (the true Harry Potter worst) in an attempt to get her, or anyone at the Ministry for that matter, to acknowledge the fact that Voldemort is back. This is a very noble thing that he does, but the moment everyone accepts that he isn't lying, Harry seems to immediately forget that a wizarding war will affect more than just Harry Potter. Suddenly everything becomes a grudge match between him and Voldemort, even though (let's be SUPER honest here) Harry is not the first person who lost their loved ones to Lord Voldemort. His life was not the only life that was ruined by He Who Shall Not Be Named, but for the entire series, Harry does not seem to understand that a war is just that... a war. Harry may have been the Chosen One, but he was only one cog in a vast machine.
3. Because of that, he treated his friends like garbage.
It's time to get real for a second. Neville Longbottom is the true MVP. He lost nearly everything to Voldemort, and yet during the most dangerous time at Hogwarts, Neville didn't run off to camp in the woods. No, he stood up to Voldemort, cut off the head of a snake, and more importantly, worked to protect the students of Hogwarts during a time when they were basically being tortured for disagreeing with the teaching staff.
Ocean Elf: Go Neville! Yes, if I had to pick a character to admit a liking, it would be him.
CATHERINE KOVACH: Do you know who didn't care about all of that? Harry Potter, that's who. Harry was so wrapped up in his own need to be the one to stop Voldemort that he didn't seem to care that all of his wizarding friends were basically trapped in a juvenile wizard prison.
Ocean Elf: Wow. Nice.
CATHERINE KOVACH: Sure, he was on an on-going mission to destroy the Horcruxes and make sure that Voldemort could die for good... but he spent half the time on that mission insisting that his friends didn't have to join him. Let's look at this. Ron is the youngest son of two well-known Muggle sympathizers and Hermione is, according to the views of the Death Eaters, a disgrace to the entire wizard community. His friends are in trouble, but Harry just whines and yells and tries to ignore the two people in his life who are willing to risk everything in order to help him. Shame on you, Harry Potter.
Ocean Elf: Selfless, my foot. This screams "I, Harry Potter, wanna be THE hero of the day!" Some might see this as Harry not wanting to endanger his friends, but if they are already being imprisoned and tortured, they are endangered. Ugh. What a mess.
CATHERINE KOVACH: 4. He was given a full ride to an amazing school, and he spent half the time copying off of his nerdy friend.
Ocean Elf: What? Lol.
CATHERINE KOVACH: How many of you are still waiting for your Hogwarts letter? Don't lie, I bet the answer is "every single one of you." Hogwarts is essentially a dream come true for literally anyone. Every single subject you can study at Hogwarts is utterly fascinating. Charms? PLEASE. Transfiguration? Oh heck yeah. Care of Magical Creatures? Bring on the unicorns! Even History of Magic is more interesting than the most interesting non-magical class you have ever taken. If I went to Hogwarts I would be studying every day, doing extra credit, and thanking my lucky stars that I'm getting a world-class magical education, living in a castle, sleeping in a four-poster bed, and eating gourmet meals three times a day.
Ocean Elf: And having to dodge out of the way of nasty blast-ended whatever those things were called, three-headed nightmare dogs, kooky ghosts and gargoyles, basilisks, bad teachers, impostors, getting killed in try wizard tournaments etc.
CATHERINE KOVACH: After a lifetime of neglect and sadness,
Ocean Elf: Oh, the Dursleys thing. That was so incredibly unnecessary. I mean what was the freaking point to that?
CATHERINE KOVACH: what does Harry do when given the magical chance of a lifetime? He barely studies, opting instead to lean heavily on help from Hermione.
5. He was pretty ungrateful.
Do you guys remember Hagrid? Hagrid was nothing but utterly devoted to Harry and his friends, going above and beyond to care for Harry. Heck, let's talk about Arthur, a man who did not have much to share, but went out of his way to share what he had with Harry ā even when it almost cost him his life. At the end of the day, who did Harry name is youngest son after? A headmaster who used him as a pawn in a grander game, and a dude who really only vaguely helped him because he had the hots for Harry's mom. Okay, it makes sense that he might not honor his current father-in-law due to the idea that maybe Ron would or due to the fact that he probably thought it was an honor enough that he married his daughter. But what about Hagrid?
Ocean Elf: Very true. He probably named his kid Albus Severus because one had to kill the other to chisel Voldy out of the pleasure of doing it himself, which still gave Voldy a kind of victory, until he finally croaked at the end of book 7.
I have to say that as far as names go, I like Albus better than Rubius. But as for characters, Hagrid definitely wins out in the personality department.
CATHERINE KOVACH: It goes deeper than that. As a child Harry loved Hagrid, visiting him any chance he got. But as he grew up, he sort of shed his devoted guardian.
Ocean Elf: Ouch!
CATHERINE KOVACH: Did Harry bother to help Hagrid with Buckbeak's trial? Did he ever once go and visit Grawp after Hagrid asked him to? Did he bother to warn Hagrid that he wasn't going to take Care of Magical Creatures anymore? No. Once he no longer really needed Hagrid, he basically stopped caring.
Ocean Elf: Holy crap! *Scowl*
CATHERINE KOVACH: This was the man who cradled Harry as a baby in Sirius' flying motorcycle, who cried at the notion of leaving poor Harry on the steps of the Dursleys...
Ocean Elf: Which was Dumbledore's idea, apparently.
CATHERINE KOVACH: what thanks did Hagrid get?
Ocean Elf: Hmmm. Good question.
*
Harry Potter Syndrome
alan Edwards wrote a great article but for some rough language, and got some amazing feedback in the comments. The original link is here, but I'm posting it all here on this page minus the colourful lingo so that all ages can read and enjoy. It's that good! I insert my own comments throughout.
* * *
Two Problems I Have with (Some) YA Fiction
Posted by Alan Edwards 2011/06/09
Alan Edwards: Iām gonna get the disclaimers out of the way first. I donāt have it out for Young Adult fiction. I respect the work that goes into it, because writing anything is hard. This post does NOT say anywhere that YA fiction sucks (except the three words before this parenthetical aside) or that itās all terrible or anything like that. Some is terrible, certainly. But I am not attacking ALL YA fiction. I have some problems with every genre, from fantasy (chainmail bikinis! Dual-wielding rangers!) to science fiction (convoluted science-like mumbo-jumbo! Space-suit bikinis!) to zombie stuff (zombies with a twist! Survivors in bikinis!) and on and on. So just so weāre clear: I do not hate ALL YA fiction. Just some. Hereās why.
Iāve written a lot of crap in my day. Some would argue that itās pretty much all I write, and to that I say, meh, okay, solid point. Iāve written training manuals, software help files, fantasy, horror, fantasy horror, fantasy training manuals of horror, exercise DVD reviews, football articles, farm tour memoirs, restaurant reviews ā you get the point. I feel like I can write in pretty much any genre if I get inspired, from romance to fanfic to tourist guides and so forth. There is, however, one genre I could never write:
Young Adult fiction.
I canāt do it. I canāt imagine doing it. It would be impossible for me to have the perspective necessary to pull it off well. However, like any critic, I sure know how to moan about something I canāt do.
I get the fact that I am far from the target audience intended for most YA fiction.
*Snip*
However, Iāve been exposed to enough of it to realize that some of it is pure and utter annoying crap. And Iām not talking about the hastily-written clones of the popular stuff, either. Iām talking major-league big-buck cash cows that get splashed hither and yon all across our great culture. Some of it is good, as accessible to adults as things targeted intentionally for them. Some of it makes me want to find the nearest crematorium and just get it all over with. There are what I consider two major flaws in approach that some YA fiction writers take. And here they are.
Letās just call this one Harry braying Potter Syndrome
Harry Potter is a beloved series of novels that Iāve seen grown men and women shove each other in long lines to get their hands on. It is also the name of the main character of the series, the most annoying little entitled wuss Iāve read who was supposed to be the hero. Seriously, if Harry Potter was in an 80ā²s movie, heād have been the privileged jerk that the Poor Kid (every 80ā²s movie had one) would have needed to out-ski or out-lacrosse or out-handball to win the affection of the Token Blond (or Nerdy Girl) and save the day. Harry Potter was the kid who got everything handed to him, the one everyone broke the rules for, and he still spent half the books moping about what a horrible freaking life he had as the Most Famousest Wizard Evar.
They might as well have named every single one of the books Harry Potter and the Deus Ex Machina. Everything he ever needed to have was handed over to him. āOh, look, my dead dad had an invisibility cloak. How wonderful for me!ā Maps, swords, brooms, whatever would come falling out of the sky for him (sometimes literally) and oh, look, Harry braying Potter saves the day again! WHAT A HERO! Every braying book had some ridiculous braying pod race, err Quidditch Match, that took 55 braying pages to describe and always came down to whoever found the hamgoddanged Lemony Snicket or whatever, no matter what was actually happening during the stupid game. Breathless accounts of who scored what and did this and did that, oh my hamgod the PuffnStuffs are going to beat the Griffindorians by 30 points or baskets or shekels or whatever the horcrux it wasā¦oh, wait, nevermind, Harry got the golden ticket and all is well. Actually, that rant was just about how braying stupid that game was, and is actually off topic.
But how did Harry get to be the great big braying hero? Oh yeah, the most expensive braying broom in the world was handed to him. He didnāt have to work for it, or do anything, or earn a hamgoddam thing. Just came in the mail. Boom. Then, when another kid gets a broom just like it and is suddenly the Bestest, hey, look, mail call, experimental Broom of Awesomeness delivered, and Harry is back to being Champeen of the World once more. Everything he had was literally handed to him.
See, thatās the problem. Most stories with heroes are about growth, in some way. Coming of age, rising above, training montages set to wicked awesome Survivor tracks. Overcoming. Learning. GROWING. Harry Potter didnāt need to do any of that. He just had to wait until someone handed him whatever the horcrux he needed to do whatever the horcrux needed to be done. It was a cop-out.
So here is todayās first bit of crappy Advice: if you write YA fiction, make sure the Hero earns his crap. Make him grow and accomplish things with only what he has on the inside and can muster from his Rag-Tag Group of Ethnically Diverse Friends. Donāt make him the Golden Child who can do no wrong and has everyone working their butt off to cover for him. Thatās annoying as hex. Also, try to curb the whining some, too. Harry Potter was a whiner. I wanted Voldemort to tear his spine out halfway through the first book.
Ocean Elf: Halt! *Urch!*
With my edits, he was doing just beautifully up until this point. *Scowl* Voldemort? Really? Bleck! That's the problem I have with most rants on anything. They always go to the opposite extreme so that whatever initial point they were making that I agreed with, I always find myself shaking my head and rolling my eyes.
Voldemort was basically the predecessor to, and the Hogwarts version of Slender Man. Both characters equally twisted, loathsome, parasitic, sick. And of course, as with Slender Man, everyone either cringed in fear of Voldy, or they doted on him in some sort of sick adoration or slave mentality. *Cough* Bellatrix* Cough, cough!*
The only differences between Voldy and Slendy besides looks were that one spoke little, the other loved the sound of his own voice and never shut up.
Voldy was as much of a whining, demanding, entitled brat as Potter, plus, he was the most loathsome, repulsive, cliche old, feces-stuffed windbag of filth, and I'd wished he had been ended with the first freaking book! But the moldy old blighter stuck around like a persistent and permeating stench to the end! I even skipped at least a couple of books, and much to my face palming dismay, Voldemort was still around in book 7.
Throughout the whole dang series, the plot remained the same, Harry VS. Voldy, Harry VS. Voldy, Harry VS. Voldy. The reason remained the same, Harry Potter had this totally awesome fabulous sparkling soul that Voldy coveted, and it was the only reason Voldy just kept after him and after him, running over anything and anyone who got in the way to try and get it. Bleh!
The rest of the series's content was forgettable and boring. I just couldn't relate to, or retain enough from the series to get anywhere near liking it a little, never mind falling in love with it as I've done with other fantasy stories I grew up on.
Alan Edwards: Ron was the braying hero. Harry was the entitled crapmouth who got the glory.
Ocean Elf: Ron was a dull little hanger-on, like everyone else in that series.
Alan Edwards: Letās Just Call This Sparkly braying Vampire Syndrome
Ocean Elf: Hahahahahaha! Twilight. I hope this part of the rant doesn't hold any disappointments.
Alan Edwards: High school was tough. I get that. Or maybe youāre still there, and in that case it IS tough. Peer pressure, bullcrap fashion ideals (I grew up when wearing the right Swatch was more important than hygiene. I wasnāt popular.), hormones, jerkface boys, catty mean girls, all of it. Itās a stage of most peopleās life that needs to be endured and survived before getting a chance to shine or blossom or whatever huggy-feely braying term there is for it. Of course, for some people, high school was the pinnacle of their achievements, looks, popularity, and success. Poor losers.
However, just because you had some crappy high school years doesnāt mean you should try to rewrite your freaking past by launching into novels about this character who just so happens to be JUST LIKE YOU AT THAT AGE, only this time, some off-beat, shady, dangerous-cool guy shows up and ignores all of the other people in the school who are smarter and nicer and prettier and falls madly in love with that shy girl. And of course, heās a braying vampire or werewolf or shape-shifting wildebeest or some crap,
Ocean Elf: Lol!
Alan Edwards: and despite the fact that heās a thousand years old, he thinks trawling the high schools for some trim is where itās at like heās Matthew McGoneawhatever in Dazed and Confused. Itās the literary equivalent of the nerdās Canadian Girlfriend. Oh yeah, in high school MY boyfriend was a totally older guy, like 100 times older than yours, and he was super-strong and handsome and loved ONLY ME and then there was this other werewolf dude who totally ALSO fell for me, and it was awesome and cool and they fought over me and I was all like āI canāt make up my mind, theyāre both so dreamy,ā and the one guy sparkled in the light and farted unicorns and the other guy was all buff and you could tell he was a monster in the sack but he wouldnāt do that with me because I was so special and stuff, and they TOTALLY respected me too because I was like all mature for my age and stuff. High school rocked.
Ocean Elf: *Laughing!*
Alan Edwards: So here is my second piece of crappy Advice: Donāt try to relive your miserable high school life by making yourself, I mean, your main character, the awesomely special love interest of every paranormal braying being that can still possibly engage in heavy petting sessions and take you, errr, your main character to the Prom and all that horsecrap. Sure, Buffy had a lot of that crap going for her, but Joss Whedon wasnāt a thin blond girl in high school (as far as I know, but Wikipedia is the beginning and end of my research materials and it didnāt say it in his bio) and not everything turned out AOK and Hunky Dorry with her vampire boyfriend.
Ocean Elf: Bleck! Buffy - who was supposed to be a vamp hunter, and she was so weak-willed that she got a vampy boyfriend - and - his freaking name was freaking "Angel" "ANGEL"! I never got into that series, but just that much knowledge of it was enough to turn me right off even giving it a chance.
Alan Edwards: So, for the love of fiction, if you must do it, aim closer towards Buffy than Twilight, please. Because undead statutory rape is pretty messed up squicking disgusting, honestly.
Ocean Elf: Better still, just don't do the vampy crush thing at all. And yes, the imprinting stuff is especially squicky. *Nauseated expression*
Steven Montano | June 9, 2011 at 4:27 pm
ā¦Iām dying hereā¦Alan, you rock. Period. End of story. Nuff said.
If for some reason I ever suffered intense brain damage and decide I need to write a YA novel, I will return to this post. This should be bronzed, framed, and Wikiāed. (āWikiāedāā¦added to Wikipediaā¦you know what Iām sayingā¦)
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 8:12 am
Hahaha I like that idea!
Digital Dame | June 9, 2011 at 4:36 pm
Oh this is beautiful :) I will admit I like HP, but I also had some issues with it. For one thing, if he was so abused and neglected by his aunt and uncle (seriously, a cupboard under the stairs to live in like a pet dog, and nothing but hand-me-down clothes his whole life while his pudgy cousin was lavished with everything under the sun? Kid should have needed trauma counseling. That aside, I see his āspecialnessā (being handed everything) on a mythological level, wherein itās the reason his story is worth telling. Would we have cared about Zeus and Athena if they hadnāt had superpowers? Probably not. Harry was like the eye of a storm: everything revolved around him but most of it was acted out by those who circled around him.
Ocean Elf: That's the whole trouble. He was the big black Gary Stu eye of the storm. As for the likes of Zeus, the only difference there was that an ancient culture actually believed in him. I do not, and I think Zeus and many other mythical characters are just as much stink face as more recently created fictional characters such as Voldemort. Ancient mythical deities do not get met with kindness by me or my cast of protagonist characters. With villains, brats, etc. that would be another story.
Digital Dame: As for Twilight, havenāt read it, donāt plan to.
Ocean Elf: Yet this commenter still felt the need to defend, albeit very politely, the craptastic Harry Friggin' Potter, in effect paraphrasing what Alan Edwards had already said.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 8:16 am
You make an excellent point about the similarity to Greek heroes of mythology. Honestly, it was one of the problems I had ārooting forā some of those heroes like Perseus, who did everything he did because it was handed to him. Still, in many of those stories, the gifts are bestowed early, and itās up to the hero to go from there. With Harry, it seemed like every time he turned around and faced a challenge, there was someone nearby to hand him The One Thing he needed to beat it. And my comments are not intended to mean I didnāt enjoy other parts of the book: I read 6 of them, after all. I just never liked Harry himself all that much.
Ocean Elf: I actually wish I hadn't wasted my time on even a single one of those books. And a comparison to Greek mythology is really stretching things. Those were mythological gods/esses, hardly in the same league, especially with the whole context being different as well as the mindset of the ancient people who worshiped these mythical entities.
Alan edwards: I never read Twilight either. This is all purely baseless conjecture. However, I still think Iām dead on.
Ocean Elf: You are. I haven't read it either, but I've looked it up on Wikipedia, plus read a good deal of what other people say about it, both for and against. Put it this way, those pro-Twilight couldn't convince me it was awesome.
Alan Edwards: And thanks a ton for coming by and commenting. =)
Jen Kirchnern | June 10, 2011 at 9:10 am
I canāt stop laughingā¦
Ocean Elf: Hehe! *Grins*
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 10:58 am
Just glad it could rise up to my hopes and expectations. Heh.
Rikki K | June 10, 2011 at 9:49 am
Iāve read quite a few YA novels, they arenāt any better or worse than other fiction in the long run. The āadult novelā equivalent of High School just happens to be corporate, political, or religious.
Really good YA that pay the debt for others: Philip Pullmanās His Dark Materials, Tamora Pierceās Beka Cooper.
I canāt complain much about HP. It got 12 year old boys to stand in line for a book release. Thatās magic right there. Lemony Snicketās series did the same thing, at least in this household where one of my teens are glued to a computer or game console at all times.
Ocean Elf: This sort of thing really irritates me. People who think reading a paper book is soooooo much better than reading something on the computer or playing video games. Please! Just because it isn't on a pile of printed pages you hold in your hands and leaf through, doesn't make it less edifying/mind-stimulating! Besides, I happen to be one of those people who cannot and never could read the printed page due to blindness, and if it were not for technology making it possible for text to be read out via screen-reader on some computers and devices, I'd still be stuck having to depend on somebody else to read me all my mail, proofread anything I type (Yes, I learned typing back in 4th grade) and reading books to me.
So cut this out!
Rikki K: Twilight I think was just āIntroduction to Paranormal Romance 101: All the angst, none of the graphic eroticaā. Iām slightly demented though, I like the thought that the half vampire child would have chewed itās way out after kicking momās insides into something resembling tapioca if dear ole dad hadnāt used his teeth as a c-section scalpel. Thatās quality gore there.
Ocean Elf: Eww no, that's nauseating tripe! No erotica? What do you call that? Oh, right, "Quality gore" *Disgusted expression*
Rikki K: I think both HP and Twilight get so much flak due to the fact that you canāt escape the rabid fans. Maybe weāve finally learned what zombies really are! 1 part popularity, 2 parts advertising, pinch of sparkle, smidgen of creativity, and half a forestās worth of paper. Voila, instant zombies. ;)
Ocean Elf: But for the whole forest thing, that last bit would've been great as a stand-alone comment. How about one part genuine interest, 2 parts hipster fanaticism, 3 parts internet cloggage, 4 parts unbearable irritation!
Yes, the rabid fans have a great deal to do with the dislike, but I wouldn't have liked those books anyway, not into vampy snog, and I don't remember much of the details in the HP books I've read, nor do I have any desire to re-read them.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 11:03 am
I agree ā there is great and mind-numbingly awful in every genre, so it certainly isnāt restricted to YA. In fact, Iām currently thinking of doing a series of posts about every genre I read, in order to beg the people who write them to stop doing bad things.
I agree that HP did get young people excited about reading, and thatās a good thing. I hope they all go on to find and read more good and interesting things, and preferably not just the stuff that rests on the bestsellerās shelf.
And I think youāre dead on about the zombies.
Christopher Simmons | June 10, 2011 at 10:25 am
Wow, just wow ā¦
Spot on, completely. Iāll echo that Achilles was a whiney little snark, much like the young Mr. Potter. Iāll also throw out there that the last book, inadvertantly, does explain why Harry doesnāt get eated by a basilisk, immolated by a dragon, etc. with the whole phylactery invulnerability issue. Doesnāt make the storytelling any better, mind you. I also love that they need a permission slip to go to Hogsmeade, but not the clearly child-abusive tri-wizard tournament that is so dangerous it might just get people you know killed.
Ocean Elf: I couldn't get my head around that either. The story seemed so full of nonsensical inconsistencies. And the whole Snape thing, talk about a disappointing anti-climax. Snape hated Harry because Harry's mommy had once jilted him for James Potter - oh, really? It all boiled down to that? Sheesh, definitely nothing worth holding out for. But then, I'm not fond of romances. I'm just fine with characters having relationships as part of the background, like interactions among friends in real life, but whenever it becomes a focal point, just, no thanks.
Christopher Simmons: Iāve been reading the Kane Chronicles, which is the Egyptian series parallel to Percy Jackson. These 11-13 year olds are acting like 17-18 year olds easily. The dialogue, vocabulary, emotional issues, and how dreamy they find Anubis, is just far too mature for their actual ages.
Ocean Elf: *Cough* Gah! another one I won't be reading.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 11:30 am
Heh ā you know, I never even thought about the Hogsmeade permission slip crap until you mentioned it. Potentially fatal tournaments? Absolutely! Sipping root beer? Whoa, whoa, whoa, letās not get crazy here.
Ocean Elf: Lol!
Alan Edwards: Iāve wondered if the trend would be to go younger and younger. Iām afraid that soon itāll be pre-schoolers swooning over the new kid with the sharp teeth and the shiny red truck.
Ocean Elf: And that's a big problem I have with YA fiction. It's mostly way too steamy, too convoluted, too shallow, too darn irritating, combination of any/all of these, yeah, and the stuff that gets insanely popular, *cough, cough* Hunger Games, just, no, so much no.
Christopher Simmons | June 10, 2011 at 11:37 am
So, you didnāt read the last twilight book, then?
Their half-vampire daughter is like ā¦ 2? Speaks likes sheās 20 and Jacob the 20something werewolf falls in love with her through some sort of non-pedophilliac non-beastiality bond ā¦
Ocean Elf: But it really is all those squicky things. The fans just don't want us saying it like it is.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 11:40 am
Holy crap. Holy crap in a streetcar. Iād accuse you of making that up if I didnāt immediately recognize that you arenāt lying. Holy crap-snacks.
Ocean Elf: Holy crap indeed! *Nodding*Breaking Dawn is a pretty unholy mess IMO.
alan edwards: No, I didnāt read it.
What the hex? Is she laughing somewhere after she bet one of her friends that she could write any messed-up thing and it would get lapped up? WHAT THE hex.
I didnāt need to know that, but Iām glad you told me.
Ocean Elf: *Can't stop laughing* I know, it's repulsive as all heck!
reconstructed | June 10, 2011 at 4:17 pm
i think part of my soul just wilted awayā¦.
Ocean Elf: Lol Oh, stop! Hahahahaha! This is making me crack up!
Christopher Simmons | June 10, 2011 at 11:51 am
Well, I think that laughing is what took place when she got the publishers to approve that one book she didnāt finish. It was supposed to be twilight retold from Edwardās perspective. I really only thought David Eddings could get away with that.
I do wonder, sometimes, if the publishers are taking novels like Riordans and saying āWow, this is a good book, but we need it for a younger demographic ā¦ why donāt you just subtract 5 years from their ages by using find/replace?ā
Ocean Elf: Hehe!
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 12:35 pm
David Eddings. Man, I have a āProblems I Have With (Some) Fantasyā post brewing, and heās gonna be prominent.
Honestly, it would surprise me if a lot of writers are doing that now. āHey I have a story to tell, but YA is hot right now, so Iāll sprinkle in some teen angst and wait for the movie deals to roll in.ā And it seems to be working.
Ocean Elf: Yes. another year, another whacked out but lame made for hormonal youth book/movie.
Christopher Simmons | June 10, 2011 at 11:54 am
Also how many hufflepuff suicides take place as they get robbed from winning the house cup each year, ācause Harry Potter killed somebody and got his house awarded just enough points from that to beat them. Itās probably also a reason for so many evil kids coming out of slytherin.
And to throw fuel to the fire, it wasnāt just that Harryās dad happened to have an invisibility cloak, he had the d&d equivalent of an artifact. Just like you described with the brooms, he doesnāt just have ācool magic items for freeā he always has the best magic item of its type.
Ok, maybe I should be working.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 12:39 pm
I can only imagine how she would have written the Lord of the Rings. The One Ring would have made everyoneās problems just go away. YAY MAGIC!
And yeah, having an entire school of Wizardry dedicated to the Second Runners-Up is like a permanent āI Was Picked Last in Kickballā support group. Are you jolly, good-natured, and non-athletic? Hufflepuff! Are you a goth? Ravenclaw! Are you potentially evil? Slytherin! Best to keep the malcontents together!ā
Working? Weāre doing it right now!
Rikki K | June 10, 2011 at 2:49 pm
Random thought relating to some of my recent YA genre reads: What is up with the playlist interspersed with the story? Is that the newest creative writing hot thing to do? Is there any backlash if the artist you mention absolutely hates your work?
If the trend of keeping with the times holds up I think we might soon see the advent of a novel written entirely in textese. That will make me put my own eyes out with a letter opener.
Ocean Elf: *Grimace* Oh, what a horrid idea! that and these songfics - bleh.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 4:25 pm
omg i no its totly gunna hapn f it hasnt already rite????
Ocean Elf: Hehe! I actually used text-speak in a section of a story, but it was a uber brat's journal, and that was how she wrote. Other characters who got a look at it were very unimpressed, though the bad typing was the least of it.
reconstructed | June 10, 2011 at 4:16 pm
Alan: āone guy sparkled in the light and farted unicornsā¦ā enough saidā¦ Iām freaking dying.
Oh and Chris Simmons I didnāt need to know the endā¦ I think part of my cerebral cortex just died!
Ocean Elf: Hahahahahahahahaha! Yep, this stuff is definitely worth editing out the f-bombs to include on my site.
Alan Edwards | June 10, 2011 at 4:26 pm
That was my reaction too. I feel like there is a part of my soul that Iāve lost for good by reading that.
Ocean Elf: Hehehehehehehe! How about that? Breaking Dawn is so awful that it doesn't even leave one's soul all in tact!
Ellie | June 11, 2011 at 8:58 am
Ha! Loved it.
I completely agree with the earlier comment about writers jumping on board the YA bandwagon. Iāve seen it time and time again, and one writer even told me she was writing YA because itās an easy market. Grrr. People should write for kids/teens because theyāre passionate about them, they know how to write for themā¦not because itās easy! Geez.
Great article! Good stuff. :)
Ocean Elf: No kidding! Well that explains why much of it is so assembly-line. The apocalyptic or post-apocalyptic settings, the dystopias, the soul-stealers/snatchers, the supposedly nice but angsty werewolf/vampire, strategically timed/placed romances, the human sacrifices, the gosh-awful weird character names, the high school angst, the Mary Sue/Gary Stus (that applies as much to canon as to fan-made characters) yep, you'll find one or a combination of those in HP, Twilight and the Hunger Games.
Alan Edwards | June 11, 2011 at 12:17 pm
Iām glad you liked it! It bothers me too when people think they can write a certain genre because they think itās āeasyā or a grab for a hot market. I donāt think anyone can write convincingly about young adults unless they really are passionate about them, like you said. Itās why I know I could never do it, because I had trouble being a teenager when I was one, heh.
Ocean Elf: Hehe! Me as well.
kendallgrey | June 13, 2011 at 9:16 am
Iāll probably get kicked in the face if anyone I know reads this, but I canāt stand Harry Potter either. I tried reading the books and only got through the third one. They just didnāt engage me. I actually enjoy the movies much more than the books.
As for Twilight, the only thing Iāll say is that people read fantasy for the fantasy. Itās all about escaping reality and rooting for the good guy. Yes, Twilight was hokey in a lot of ways, but for me, it brought back memories and some of the feelings I hadnāt experienced since high school. I enjoyed the books. I also see your point. But itās not real life. Itās entertainment. Iām okay with it.
Great post as always, my friend!
Alan Edwards | June 13, 2011 at 10:04 am
Well, the chances of anyone reading this are encouragingly slim, so I think youāll be safe.
I read the first 4 or 5 books for reasons I have no interest in discussing, but it wasnāt something I would have picked up on my own (for some reason, hearing about this Awesome Hot New Thing that everyoneās raving about makes me instantly dislike it. I guess Iām a contrarian. Or maybe just an arsehole).
Ocean Elf: No, that's definitely not being an arse. I'm the same way. Trends tend to annoy the living heck out of me, and when they are things I wouldn't give a dang about to begin with - vampy love, a story about some little witchcraft school for little wizards, a post-apocalyptic dystopia where kids starve and kill each other in some twisted sort of olympics as a perverse form of entertainment - uh, no thanks, pass, I just don't see the appeal.
Alan Edwards: I wasnāt a huge fan, but Harry and Quidditch in particular made me actively annoyed.
Based on some of the garbage I read for pleasure, far be it from me to argue with your point about people reading fantasy for the fantasy. What I have a problem with isnāt necessarily something that anyone else would take issue with, and enjoying what you read is the most important thing.
Thanks for the blog-love, and you rock.
Tim | June 13, 2011 at 11:05 am
its bad that the key takeaway I got from this article was: āHoly crap TWO TVās in the living room! *click new window to bestbuyā¦*ā
Ocean Elf: Heh - that was the bit of ramble I snipped out since it really wasn't relevant.
Tim: I think there was some other stuff after that, but i was too busy jumping around the living singing my new ātwo tvs for meā song.
Ocean Elf: I would always like to get more in the way of electronics, but that doesn't matter.
Alan Edwards | June 14, 2011 at 12:25 pm
Itās the question we get most often from people looking to see the house (itās for sale) ā why 2 TVs? Itās also great for the Super Bowl, so the Puppy Bowl can be running at the same time as the game.
Dan | March 22, 2012 at 5:01 pm
You missed the hunger games. Just hakcneyed stream of consciousness, plagiarized bullsh, And the characters dont get me started, wooden, and named by syphilitic retards. Katniss? Peeta?
Ocean Elf: Exactly!!! *Beams* Finally, someone else who dislikes The Hunger Games and for at least some of the same reasons!
Dan" Nambla?
Ocean Elf: ROFL!!
Dan: (ok that last one I made up, still)
Ocean Elf: Good job at satirizing though! The Peeta thing makes me literally cringe, and anyone who has heard of the most notorious animal rights group would understand why. So this comment is some dang good comedy!
Ivan | March 25, 2012 at 1:22 am
After the Hunger Games was released, I feel as if I have successfully become a YA fiction hater.
Ocean Elf: Hehe! Me as well. Ugh! It just keeps going from bad to worse. Although, to be accurate, I dislike the term "hater" since it's what anyone who dislikes this crap and its fan cults gets called by sorehead fans.
Ivan: As a comment on the Rotten Tomatoes stated very well, āThis is what I was afraid was going to happen. Itās a shame because this could have been so great. Instead itās another book turned into a mindless movie for the masses that every screaming fan girl will love while bashing anyone who gives it a negative review.ā
Ocean Elf: Heck yes!
Ivan: Of course, the film adaptation of any book should never be expected to exceed the quality of the original book itself, but you can tell a lot about the book, its film, and their stories simply by its genre.
Ocean Elf: True - with fad young adult or youth fiction, a movie is sure to follow very shortly. With a real classic that doesn't have such a raving fan base, that all ages can get into, the movie tends to take much longer to produce. Or so it seems.
Ivan: How can you do that?
A genre, to me, classifies the book for a targeted audience ā and generally, individuals in the targeted audience share similar characteristics. Whenever I see the term āyoung adultā, I automatically default the phrase to āimmature teenagerā in most contexts.
Ocean Elf: *Grins* Yep, and the group thinking fan cults have made sure of that happening, whether they are Twitards, bronies, Potterheads or otaku.
Ivan: I canāt be bothered to read the book or watch the film. Iāve done enough research on various websites to understand the story and film. Those who argue that āyou canāt judge a film (or book, in most cases) by its synopsisā are the same people that I find who enjoy enveloping themselves in their own fictional world. Like anything, of course, exceptions exist.
The Hunger Games isnāt one of them.
Ocean Elf: *Pleased grin* Oh, wow, I haven't read this much refreshing stuff in a while! :) There is hope for the human race!
Dan | March 26, 2012 at 7:23 am
You said it friend,
YA today seems to mean āfor screaming tweens onlyā. And you dont have to be 8-12 to be a tween anymore, just look at any of the twilight premiers and youāll see that the 40+ crowd can be just as loud and irritating and facepalm inducing.
Ocean Elf: Heck yes, I can believe it. After seeing trampy little high school trolls and a pre-middle-aged woman duke it out in a massive internet fight over stupid Gundam Wing, I believe it!
Dan: Can you believe that Tolkienās trilogy used to be considered YA? When I was in high school, almost no one I knew had ever recreationally read a book, let alone the holy trilogy. Intelligence continues to die in America.
Ocean Elf: Yes, well, that explains why it eventually got turned into an irritating fad with a movie featuring some eye-candy actor for the swooning fangirls too. And it was a far better story than what passes for literature going on the market for youth today.
Ivan | March 26, 2012 at 7:28 pm
Perhaps I should adjust my views then! I was not aware that LOTR was once considered YA ā if what you say is true, perhaps I do not dislike the YA genre after all. I have not read any books or watched any films from the LOTR movies, but Iāve been exposed to enough ābits and piecesā of it from various sources to inevitably conclude that it actually IS as good of a story as people say it is.
Absolute fiction and complete ridiculousness are acceptable for me (I elaborate in the next paragraph), so long as they are not just flashy effects, sexual innuendos (perhaps even the actual thing as well), mindless violence, or simply put, the things that people talk about after the movie ended.
Itās not fair to ask the film industry to constantly produce something novel and satisfying for their audience, but I personally prefer a bit more substance. Hunger Games, if my research was correct, essentially revolved around a dystopia, but inaccurately captured the seriousness of true hunger. Films like Children of Men are true highlights of dystopias for myself.
Thatās probably enough digressing for me though; I think you really hit the nail on the point: Intelligence continues to die in America.
However, let us not forget that modern movies, unfortunately, are mainly produced to satisfy the eyes and not the mind.
Ocean Elf: Which is the problem right there. Combine that shallowness with groupthink, and, oy.
Ivan: Have hope, friend! The kind of hope that creative freedom is actually on a social pendulum that will swing so far to āless valueā and āmore eye candyā that it will some day swing back to a compromise between movie magic and true substance.
triscellepublishing | April 17, 2013 at 5:15 pm
LOLā¦Iām rolling. The sad thing is for awhile I was a YA librarian, but I hated the majority of YA fic for these reasons youāve mentioned. Thank you!!!!
Ocean Elf: Yes! :)
ā
Back to Harry Potter And The Twilight Hunger Games
Comment options: